英國師資培育認證制度之探究

A Study of Teacher Education/Training Accreditation System in England and Wales

李奉儒
Feng-Jihu Lee


所屬期刊： 第7卷第1期 「教師培育與專業發展」
主編：國立臺灣師範大學講座教授
楊深坑
系統編號： vol024_03
主題： 師資培育
出版年份： 2011
作者： 李奉儒
作者(英文)： Feng-Jihu Lee
論文名稱： 英國師資培育認證制度之探究
論文名稱(英文)： A Study of Teacher Education/Training Accreditation System in England and Wales
共同作者：
最高學歷：
校院名稱：
系所名稱：
語文別：
論文頁數： 30
中文關鍵字： 英國;師資培育;師資培育認證;師資培育評鑑
英文關鍵字： England;Wales;Teacher Education/ Training Accreditation;accreditation;evaluation
服務單位： 國立中正大學教育學研究所教授
稿件字數： 18382
作者專長： 教育哲學;批判教學論;道德教育;後設倫理學;比較教育理論;英國教育研究
投稿日期： 2011/2/8
論文下載： pdf檔案icon
摘要(中文)： 本文運用歷史研究法以掌握英國師資培育認證制度的六個面向，包括師資培育認證的政策與相關法規、認證的權責機關與成員、認證的硬體層面（包括圖儀、經費與空間等）、認證的軟體層面（包括教師、課程與教學等）、認證的實施方案，以及認證結果之運用措施等。最後，根據研究結果提供我國未來實施及檢討改進師資培育機構認證制度之參考。
本研究之主要發現如下：
一、英國師資培育認證政策與相關法規之修正與訂定受到政治意識型態的影響，特別是近二十年來新保守主義與新自由主義對於師資培育的嚴格批評所帶來的衝擊。
二、英國師資培育認證的權責機構與成員隨著政府的集權化而跌有變遷，成員所代表的教育專業性格逐漸弱化。
三、英國師資培育認證的硬體層面如圖書、儀器、空間、經費等有詳細的規定。
四、英國師資培育認證的軟體層面如師資、課程與教學漸採能力本位模式，目前主要的依據是師資職前培育國定課程以規範未來教師的證照標準和國家指標。
五、英國師資培育認證的實施程序有明確規範以管理師資培訓機構的運作與提供的課程內容。
六、英國師資培育認證結果的運用包含通過或不通過申請、撤銷機構認證以及重新認證。
摘要(英文)： In order to understand the development of Teacher Education Accreditation System in England and Wales, this research first of all employs historical method to study some specific aspects of accreditation which this research will pay particular attention to: 1.the policies and acts/regulations of teacher education/training accreditation, 2.the agencies and their membership for accrediting teacher education, 3.the hard dimensions, and 4.the soft dimensions of teacher education accreditation, 5.the procedures of teacher education accreditation, and 6.the treatment of accreditation results.
The following are the main findings of this research:
1.The policies and acts/regulations of teacher education/training accreditation systems in England and Wales are greatly influenced by the attacks from neo-conservativism and neo-liberalism.
2.The central agencies and their members for accrediting teacher education have been changed as educationally de-professionalized.
3.The hard dimensions of teacher education accreditation systems, including libraries, equipments, funding and spaces are regulated in detail by government.
4.The soft dimensions of teacher education accreditation systems, including teacher educators, curriculum, teaching methods, assessments, and so on are increasingly competence-based and follow the Qualified Teacher Status standards and Initial Teacher Training requirements.
5.The procedures and executive programs of institutional accreditation of teacher education are conducted by then Teacher Training Agency and later Training and Development Agency for Schools after 2005.
6.The treatment of accrediting results includes pass or not accreditation or re-accreditation, and might be withdraw of accreditation after Ofsted’s inspection..
Finally, this study in concluding, according to the research results, proposes some suggestions for the improvement of teacher education accreditation system in Taiwan.
參考文獻： 李奉儒譯（2004）。歷史研究。載於黃光雄審閱總校正，教育研究法：規劃與評鑑（頁764-796）。高雄：麗文。
李奉儒（2005）。英國中小學教師素質管理機制之研究。比較教育，58，135-171。
李奉儒（2006）。我國中小學教師評鑑機制規劃之芻議：英國的經驗與啟示。教育研究與發展期刊，2（3），193-216。
李奉儒（2008a）。中央集權與教育市場：英國師資培育制度變革之研究。教育研究與發展，4（1），55-82。
李奉儒（2008b）。師資培育。載於國立教育資料館（編印），中華民國96年教育年報（頁225-274）。臺北：國立教育資料館。
李奉儒（2009）。師資培育。載於國立教育資料館（編印），中華民國97年教育年報（頁241-287）。臺北：國立教育資料館。
李奉儒（2010）。師資培育。載於國立教育資料館（編印），中華民國98年教育年報（頁263-302）。臺北：國立教育資料館。
李奉儒、蘇永明、黃淑玲（1998）。英國實習輔導教師制度研究（NSC86-2413-H-260-003）。國科會專題研究計畫成果報告。台北：國科會。
康萃婷、李奉儒（2007）。英國2005-2011之合格教師地位授予的師資職前培訓視導架構。比較教育，63，192-205。
陳奎?（1977）。英國師範教育之現況與發展趨勢。教育資料集刊，2，117-134。
教育部（2005）。追求卓越師資培育品質，共創未來教育願景。2005 年9 月30 日公告，2006 年8 月21 日取自http://epaper.edu.tw/news/940930/940930c.htm
教育部中部辦公室（2006）。師資培育素質提升方案。南投：著者。
楊深坑（2006）。國家管理、市場機制與德國近年來師資培育之改革。教育研究與發展期刊，2（1），119-143。
Accreditation Committee: Terms of Reference。2010年11月13日，資料下載於：http://www.tda.gov.uk/partners/funding/accreditation/accredcommittee.aspx
Adams, Anthony & Tulasiewicz,Witold (1995). The crisis in teacher education: An European concern? London, UK: Falmer Press.
Alexander, Robin; Craft, Maurice & Lynch, James (Eds.)(1984). Change in teacher education: Context and provision since Robbins. London, UK: Holt.
Amaral, A. & Magalhaes, A. (2004). Epidemiology and the Bologna Saga, Higher Education 48, 79-100.
Barton, L., Pollard, A. &Whitty, G. (1992). Experiencing CATE: The impact of accreditation upon initial training institutions in England. Journal of Education for Teaching, 18 (1), 41-57.
DES (1984 a). Education Act 1984. London, UK: DES.
DES (1984 b). Initial teacher training: Approval of courses (Circular 3/84). London, UK: DES.
DES (1989a). Qualified teacher status: A consultation document. London, UK: HMSO.
DES (1989b). Initial teacher training: Approval of courses (Circular 24/89). London, UK: DES.
DES (1992). Reform of initial teacher training: A consultation document. London, UK: HMSO.
DfEE (1997a). Teachers: Meeting the challenge of change (Green Paper). London, UK: DfEE.
DfEE (1997b). The initial teacher training national curriculum (Circular 10/97). London, UK: DfEE
DfEE (1998). Circular 4/98: Requirements for courses of initial teacher training. London, UK: DfEE.
DfE/WO (1993). The Government’s proposals for the reform of initial teacher training. London, UK: DfE/WO.
DfE (1994). Education Act 1994. London, UK: DfE.
European Commission (2004). Improving the education of teachers and trainers. Brussels, Belgium: Eurydice.
Eurydice, the information network on education in Europe (2006). Quality assurance in teacher education in Europe. Brussels, Belgium: Eurydice.
Furlong, J. (2001). Re-forming teacher education, re-forming teachers: Accountability, professionalism and competence. In R. Phillips & J. Furlong (Eds.), Education, reform and the state: Twenty-five years of politics, policy, and practice (pp.118-135). London, UK: RoutledgeFalmer.
Furlong, J. & Maynard, T. (1995). Mentoring student teachers: The growth of professional knowledge. London, UK: Routledge.
Furlong, J.; Barton, L.; Miles, S.; Whiting, C.; and Whitty, G. (2000). Teacher education in transition: Re-forming professionalism? Buckingham, UK: Open University Press.
Landman, M. & Ozga, J. (1995). Teacher education policy in England. In M. B. Ginsburg & B. Lindsay (Eds.), The political dimension in teacher education: Comparative perspectives on policy formation, socialization, and society (pp.23-39). London, UK: Falmer Press.
Ofsted (2005). Framework for the inspection of initial teacher training for the award of Qualified Teacher Status 2005-2011. London, UK: Ofsted.
Ofsted & TTA (1996). Framework for the assessment of quality and standards in initial teacher training 1996/97. London, UK: Ofsted.
Patrick, H. (1986). From Cross to CATE: the universities and teacher education over the past century, Oxford Review of Education, 12 (3), 243-261.
Pimm, D. & Sellinger, M. (1995). The commodiffication of teaching: Teacher education in England. In Marvin F. Widen & Peter P. Grimmett (Eds.). Changing times in teacher education: Restructuring or reconceptualization? (pp. 47-66) London, UK: Farmer.
Taylor,William (1990). The control of teacher education: the Council for Accreditation of Teacher Education. In Norman J. Graves (Ed). Initial teacher education: Policies and progress. London, UK: Beekman Books Inc
Teacher Training Agency (1997). Training curriculum and standards for new teachers. London, UK: TTA.
Teacher Training Agency (1999). Procedures for the withdrawal of institutional accreditation and mechanisms for a request for reconsideration. London, UK: TTA.
Training and Development Agency for Schools (2007). Procedures for addressing non-compliance in initial teacher training and the withdrawal of institute accreditation. London, UK: TDA.
Training and Development Agency for Schools (2010). Guidance to accompany the Professional Standards for Qualified Teacher Status and Requirements for Initial Teacher Training. London, UK: TDA.
Wilkin, M. (Ed.)(1996). Initial teacher training: The dialogue of ideology and culture. London, UK: Falmer.
Wise, Arthur E. (2005). Establishing teaching as a profession: The essential role of professional accreditation. Journal of Teacher Education, 56 (4), 318-331.